Rising Waters fellows in Mumbai in January
Photo credit: Photography Promotion Trust
On a brisk day last December, students in the course Liquid Histories and Floating Archives walked along a stretch of the Schuylkill River, as they had done each week of the fall semester. On this particular day, they were applying sheets of paper to concrete walls, metal poles, and railings at Schuylkill Banks Park as part of a final project by urban studies major Lucy Corlett, C’20.
Along with a simple line drawing of the river, each paper contained the first and last stanzas of a poem called “Lines Written on Leaving Philadelphia,” composed in 1824 by the 19th-century Irish poet Thomas Moore. Corlett discovered the poem in an online archive documenting the history of Philadelphia’s watershed.
“A notable Irish poet from the 19th century lived for a time in Philadelphia near the Schuylkill River and wrote about it,” says Corlett, who used water-soluble paper and inks and wheat-paste glue so that the project would not leave permanent marks on the landscape. “So I thought, ‘How can I bring these archives out to the place that they’re about, and to the people who walk along the Schuylkill like Thomas Moore did?’”
The multi-disciplinary Liquid Histories course, taught by Bethany Wiggin, Associate Professor of German and Founding Director of the Penn Program in Environmental Humanities, examined how sea-level rise in a time of climate change is transforming urban environments.
“In the class we explored the way local knowledge shapes how we understand the global problem of sea-level rise from our vantage point in Philadelphia,” says Wiggin. “We read about our urban waterways, their history and future, and we walked alongside them to experience them and to have those encounters shape how we approached more analytic course materials.” The students reflected on what they had learned in a collaborative blog post.
Liquid Histories was one part of a larger undertaking called Rising Waters: Philadelphia and Mumbai, an ethnographic and historical research project exploring river and coastal cities, led by Wiggin and Nikhil Anand, Assistant Professor of Anthropology. Anand taught the first Rising Waters undergraduate course at Penn in spring 2018, and co-taught the second in Mumbai last fall at the Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS).
Rising Waters engages institutionally based student research fellows in both cities over a three-year period. It is supported by Penn Arts and Sciences’ Making a Difference in Diverse Communities initiative, which assembles interdisciplinary teams of faculty members to work with undergraduates in underserved communities to explore issues of inequality and diversity.
Lucy Corlett, C'20
Photo credit: Brooke Sietinsons
In January, Wiggin, Anand, and six undergraduate Rising Waters fellows traveled to Mumbai for a Winter Intensive seminar with faculty and six student counterparts at TISS.
“The three-day intensive in Mumbai was sort of a works-in-progress workshop, where both students at Penn and in Mumbai had been thinking about and working on their projects for about four to five months,” Anand says. “The focus was not just on advising the path forward, but also on how their research might engage the wider public.”
Philadelphia and Mumbai share a history of industrial development on drained tidal wetlands that have been heavily settled by energy and port infrastructures. As the climate warms, rising waters and extreme weather events threaten the infrastructure, exacerbate social inequalities, and degrade remaining natural areas. Rising Waters participants hope to imagine alternative visions for water use, conservation, and equity in the two cities.
Wiggin says the 12 fellows connected almost immediately. “I think they recognized in one another a shared sensibility about the importance of stewardship of our local environments,” she says. “And they also recognized their mutual talents and passion for collaborative work.”
The Mumbai intensive had three main components: a series of presentations by thinkers, artists, and activists working with urban waters in different contexts; two days of student workshops and activities, including a field trip to the east coast of Mumbai, where most of the city’s port infrastructure historically has been; and a series of public events, including an outdoor exhibition of photographs by Sudharak Olwe exploring urban waterscapes and unequal access to water in Mumbai.
Anand points out that water inequality is not exclusive to Mumbai but exists in Philadelphia as well. “In the course that I taught last spring, we learned that over ten thousand households in Philadelphia faced water shutoffs because they could not afford to pay their bills,” he says. “In Mumbai, on the other hand, often the city won’t bill low-income residents for water—won’t extend them that formal access, so they have to get it in other ways such as paying under the table or paying a neighbor.”
Anand and Wiggin say that marginalized populations in both cities tend to live on what used to be wetlands. “With climate change, it’s those populations that are put in harm’s way,” Anand explains. “Our question was, ‘What can we learn from these shared histories of marginalization, and how might we think about other ways to inhabit these cities, particularly when floods and extreme weather events are becoming more frequent?’”
The students’ projects fell roughly into three clusters. One cluster looked at riverscapes; another at water rights and sanitation, including pollution from petrochemicals; and the third explored new ways of managing water resources—such as rainwater harvesting, revitalizing canals, and redevelopment of port areas.
Wiggin says the field trip to Mumbai’s port lands revealed similar approaches in both cities. “We learned about the plans that the Mumbai Port Trust has for the city’s port lands, and they resonated so strongly with what we’ve been learning through Rising Waters Fellow [and College senior] Rose Nagele’s project exploring the redevelopment of the Philadelphia Navy Yard.”
Public engagement and dissemination of research are crucial parts of Rising Waters. Students in both cities interacted with practitioners from various disciplines, including a residency at Penn by climate journalist Eric Holthaus. Wiggin and Anand will present the research findings in publications and at academic conferences in history, anthropology, and environmental humanities. Student projects will be posted online, and plans are in the works for both virtual and “real” river tours and exhibits meant to engage the public.
By focusing on two vastly different cities, Rising Waters: Philadelphia and Mumbai seeks to envision a range of new approaches to urban waters and adaptations to climate change that can be applied to other locations.
“The echoes across these two cities really resounded,” says Wiggin, “from traces and inheritances of the British Navy and wetland loss to toxic remnants of petroleum refineries to concerns about equity and gentrification. Alarmingly, in both places there was little evident planning concerning how sea level rise will impact the future. But these talented young students get it—and they, too, are the future.”
